Nilabha Saha, IIT Bombay

Description

Presentation
Speaker: Nilabha Saha, IIT Bombay
Host: Rekha Santhanam
Title: Extending to a Model Structure Is Not a First-Order Property
Time, day and date: 3:00:00 PM – 4:00:00 PM, Tuesday, May 05
Venue: Ramanujan Hall
Abstract: A model structure on a category equips it with three distinguished classes of morphisms (weak equivalences, cofibrations, and fibrations) satisfying axioms that enable homotopy-theoretic constructions. A natural question arises: given a category C and a chosen subcategory W of "weak equivalences," when can we complete the pair (C, W) to a full model structure?
In this talk, we present the main results of Droz and Zakharevich (2021), who answer this question completely when C is a poset. They characterise precisely which pairs (C, W) admit a model structure in terms of a functorial "choice of centers," and show that for countable posets this existence condition is first-order expressible. The main theorem, however, establishes that no such first-order characterisation exists in general: there are pairs that satisfy all the same first-order properties as extendable ones, yet do not themselves extend to a model structure.
We will develop the necessary background on model categories and state the relevant results from first-order logic (in particular, the Lowenheim--Skolem theorem) during the talk. A working knowledge of basic category theory (functors, limits, colimits) will be assumed. Prior familiarity with model structures may help in appreciating the content, but is not a hard prerequisite.

Location
Ramanujan Hall
Date
Tue, May 5, 2026
Start Time
3:00pm-4:00pm IST
Duration
1 hour
Priority
5-Medium
Access
Public
Updated
Mon, May 4, 2026 3:29pm IST